The flat rate on your vests may have left you thousands short. Find the gap before December 31, close it the cheap way, and keep April boring.
Your RSUs vested. Shares hit your brokerage account. Some got sold or held back to "cover taxes." Done, right?
Maybe not.
Every year I see the same pattern with executives. Salary is fine. Bonus is fine. Then April shows up with a five- or six-figure balance due, sometimes with an underpayment penalty stapled to it. Nothing went wrong. Nobody made a mistake on the return. The tax was simply never fully collected in the first place.
Here's why, and the checklist to run with your CPA in the next few weeks, while you can still fix it cheaply.
The mechanism: a flat rate meets a progressive bracket
When RSUs vest, the value is ordinary income. Your employer treats it as "supplemental wages," the same bucket as bonuses.
For supplemental wages, the IRS lets employers withhold federal income tax at a flat 22%. That rate only becomes 37% on supplemental wages above $1 million in a calendar year. Most payroll systems use the flat rate because it's simple.
Now look at the 2026 federal brackets:
35% starts at $256,225 of taxable income for single filers and $512,450 for married couples filing jointly.
37% starts at $640,600 single and $768,700 married filing jointly.
If your income puts your vests in the 32%, 35%, or 37% bracket, every vested dollar withheld at 22% is under-withheld by 10 to 15 cents. Federal only. State tax is its own question.
What that looks like in dollars
A simple, hypothetical example. Not anyone's real return.
A married executive's salary already puts the household in the 35% bracket. During 2026, $200,000 of RSUs vest.
Withheld at 22%: $44,000
Tax at 35% (if all of it lands in that bracket): $70,000
Gap on the RSUs alone: $26,000
Add a bonus withheld the same way, a spouse's income, a capital gain from selling shares, and state tax, and the gap grows. Some households see the opposite and get a refund. The point isn't that everyone owes. The point is that the default withholding was never designed around your bracket, so you have to check.
Two more quiet leaks:
Additional Medicare Tax. Employers withhold the extra 0.9% only on wages over $200,000 from that employer. For married couples, the tax applies above $250,000 of combined wages. Two earners who each make under $200,000 can owe it with nothing withheld.
Non-qualified stock options are supplemental wages too, and the same flat-rate logic applies when you exercise. (ISOs are a different animal: no withholding at exercise, but possible AMT. That's its own post.)
Why this matters now, not in April
Two reasons.
1. The penalty runs on timing, not just totals. The IRS expects tax to come in during the year. If it doesn't, you can owe an underpayment penalty, figured like interest. For the fourth quarter of 2026, that rate is 7% a year, compounded daily. It's not catastrophic. It's also completely avoidable.
2. Withholding has a superpower that estimated payments don't. Federal tax withheld from your paycheck is generally treated as if it were paid evenly across the year, even if it actually came out in December. An estimated payment counts on the day you make it. So extra withholding in December can patch a gap from April. A January check usually can't.
That superpower has a clock. When you hand your employer a new Form W-4, they have until the first payroll period ending on or after the 30th day after they receive it to put it into effect. If you're reading this in mid-November, that clock is already tight. Don't wait for December.
The safe-harbor targets: the two numbers that matter
You generally avoid the federal underpayment penalty if your withholding plus on-time estimated payments cover the smaller of:
90% of your 2026 tax, or
100% of your 2025 tax, which becomes 110% if your 2025 adjusted gross income was over $150,000 ($75,000 if married filing separately).
You also generally owe no penalty if the balance due is under $1,000.
For most executives, the useful target is the second one, because it's a known number. Your 2025 total tax is already printed on last year's return. Multiply by 1.10. That's your line.
Important: safe harbor protects you from the penalty, not from the bill. If 2026 was a big vest year, you can hit 110% of last year's tax and still owe a large balance in April. That's fine, as long as the cash is sitting there waiting for it.
The year-end withholding checklist
Run this with your CPA. Most of it takes an hour.
This week (by Fri, Nov 20)
Pull three documents. Your latest pay stub (year-to-date federal withholding), your stock plan account (vests so far and how much was withheld), and your 2025 Form 1040 (total tax and AGI).
List what's still coming. Remaining paychecks, any December vests, year-end bonus, option exercises, and any planned stock sales. Note the dates.
Next week (by Wed, Nov 25)
Get a projection. Ask your CPA for a 2026 estimate, including state. You want two numbers: projected total tax, and your safe-harbor target (110% of 2025 tax if your 2025 AGI was over $150,000).
Find your gap. Safe-harbor target minus year-to-date withholding and estimated payments, minus what's still expected to be withheld. That's your penalty gap. Projected tax minus everything paid is your April gap. They're different numbers. Know both.
Before your December payrolls
Close the penalty gap with withholding first. On a new W-4, Step 4(c) lets you add a flat extra amount per paycheck. Divide the gap by your remaining pay periods. Submit it as soon as your number is ready, so payroll has time to apply it.
Check your December vest. Some stock plans let you elect a higher withholding rate on vests than the default 22%. Ask your stock plan administrator. If yours does, it's often the cleanest fix.
Write a reminder to undo it. Extra withholding set for 2026 will keep coming out in 2027 until you change it. Put a calendar note for the first week of January.
By Jan 15, 2027
Use an estimated payment for what's left. The fourth 2026 installment is due January 15, 2027. Late-year income, like a December stock sale, is what this payment is for. If your income was lumpy, ask your CPA whether the annualized income method on Form 2210 lowers or eliminates the penalty for earlier quarters.
Before you file
Fund the April gap now. If safe harbor is covered but you'll still owe, set the money aside in cash. Don't plan to sell stock in April to pay a bill you can see in November. A forced sale on a deadline is how a tax problem becomes an investment problem.
Check your 1099-B. RSU shares sold to cover taxes often show a cost basis of $0 or a missing basis on the broker form. Make sure your CPA adjusts it so you're not taxed twice on the same income.
Decision rules you can hand your CPA
If you want the short version, here it is:
If year-to-date withholding is below 110% of last year's tax (or 100% if your 2025 AGI was $150,000 or less) → close the gap with extra W-4 withholding before December 31.
If you can't get enough withholding in before year-end → make the January 15 estimated payment, and ask about the annualized method.
If you've met safe harbor but still owe a big balance → no penalty, but set the cash aside now.
If a single vest pushes your supplemental wages past $1 million → the excess is withheld at 37%. Check whether that over-withholds you if you're not in the top bracket.
If you expect 2027 to look anything like 2026 → fix the default in January, not next November.
The bigger point
Withholding is a default someone else set for you. Defaults are built for the average employee, not for someone whose comp is half stock.
The executives who never get surprised in April aren't smarter about taxes. They just ran the numbers in November and set a rule.
Rules over feelings. Boring is the goal.
If you want to see how much of your equity you actually keep after tax, run your numbers in our free Exec Comp Optimizer: https://www.forecastcapitalmanagement.com/exec-comp-optimizer
And if you'd like a member of our team to look at how your vests, taxes, and concentration fit together in one plan, start a conversation here, and we'll reply within one business day: https://www.forecastcapitalmanagement.com/start
This article is for educational purposes only and is not tax, legal, or investment advice. Tax rules are complex, change often, and depend on your specific situation. Figures cited are 2026 federal amounts as published by the IRS; state rules vary. Examples are hypothetical and for illustration only. Please consult your own CPA or tax advisor before making any changes to your withholding or estimated payments.